Today’s WTF design decision of the week goes to the survey designers for the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, who decided purple text with a green background color was a good idea.
Me (working on a month 3 of the same huge prototype): OK, so I need this cell to be 110px wide…
Internet Explorer 8: OH HAI I see you want this last cell to be 110px wide. I can do that no problem but first Imma gonna shift the contents of the cell to align left, mmkay?
Me: What?!? No!
Internet Explorer 8: Yup.
Me: Okaaaaay, what if I add a class=”right”, will you put it back?
IE8: Nuh uh.
Me: Align right? tbody class=”right”?
IE8: LALALALA I CAN’T HEEEAR YOU….
Me: (searches web frantically….) OK, this makes NO sense, but this cell’s in a table with a width of 100%…. so if I set the width of the cell to 13% instead of 110 px…?
IE8: Hey, I see you want to make the width of this cell 13% so Imma gonna put this cell back to right alignment, mmkay?
Me: I hate you.
There’s security, and then there’s stupidity.
We’re all familiar by now with the security pattern where you set up 2-3 questions that “only you” will know the answer to (well, only you and people who know you really well, anyway) in addition to your username and password. It essentially sets up a two-password system. If you can’t answer the first password (your security question’s answer) you never get to the second password, thus securing it.
I have a lot of problems with that security pattern, which I won’t get into here, because this post isn’t about the security, it’s about the stupidity. It’s security when you ask me to set up a double-password system. Since it’s critical information, it’s good design and good sense to ask me to review the information before I submit it, and print it for my records. One password is hard enough to remember, but this pattern essentially asks me to set up three.
It’s stupidity when you decide that your security policies need to be strong that when you ask me to review my information for accuracy, you obscure the answers to my questions.
And yet… that’s what we have here.
I’m willing to guess that the vast majority of people are not dumb enough to fill out a registration form for a medical billing website on the Jumbotron of their local stadium, or anywhere else that would allow a significant number of people to view the process. So why make that registration even harder by blocking the review of critical account-access-granting information? It’s security absurdity.